The Supreme Court of Nova Scotia gave Flying Cow (a newsletter distributed in, among other places, restaurants and coffee shops) a slap on the wrist recently, handing down a $239,000 fine and a finding that Flying Cow infringed on the copyright of a national publisher. Justice Richard (the judge who heard the case) held that Flying Cow's activities clearly infringed the copyright of The Coffee News of Manitoba and that Flying Cow had acted in an effort to confuse advertisers. The trial was held over five days in November, 2005 in Halifax.
The Coffee News is trade-marked and published in about 50 countries and operates on a franchise basis with each of the publications having the same format, colour and style.
From my perspective neither the finding nor the appeal (the owner of flying cow has indicated in a press release that he would appeal the decision) are particularly relevant except to point out to business owners that you have to be careful in what you do and the names you choose to use in your business. It also shows the power of actually registering your copyright and trade-marks with the Canadian Intellectual Property Office. Doing so can give you a head start in any disputes which arise with other companies.
The only other point I would like to make with respect to the case is that, if you are involved in a franchised business, you should be extremely careful if you decide that you want to strike out on your own and open up a competing business which may use business methods, proprietary information, or other property of the franchisor.
Recent Comments